October 29, 2011
Do we prefer flawed characters?
Andrew Sullivan discusses whether we are drawn to flawed characters because we can relate to them. What do you think?
Latest Announcements
Recent Comments
-
Recent Posts
Archives
This entry was posted in Stories. Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post.
Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.
Rachel
Permalink
I think it depends on how they are flawed.
If they are flawed, it makes them more human and more believable. Then, when the characters overcome their trials, or improve on their flaws, it is inspiring for us as readers. It is not very inspiring to read about an already perfect character achieving things. It is too predictable and therefore boring and it is impossible to relate to. We can relate to characters who struggle against things, who make mistakes just as we do. When they succeed we cheer them on.
However, I think that if the character’s flaws involve things that are strongly against our own values and beliefs, we may have a harder time relating to them and liking them. That’s why most people are drawn to the heroes in books and not the villains, even when both the hero and the villain each have their own flaws. Just look at Harry and Voldemort.
Mary
Permalink
No one is perfect. That’s the long and short of it. So to bounce off of Rachel’s comment, yeah it makes them more believable, which is more enjoyable to read. While I love being drawn into a world of fantasy and fun times, I also enjoy stories of real struggle that they have to overcome. That involves struggle, which usually can bring out the worst and best of us. Just ask any student in the middle of finals or midterms. Those who have flaws and work to use them to their advantage are the best type of characters that we love to struggle with, hoping that they will eventually defeat the odds.
That being said, a person who’s just filled with flaws and doing nothing to improve their situation ends up being tiring. If your flaw is preventing you from getting what you want and you do nothing about it–either just expect the world to change to fit your view or whine… I lose interest very quickly.
As an actor, I would never want to play someone perfect, because that’s just not feasible. Every person is capable of anything under the right circumstances. Flaws are fun and make characters full. Harry still needs to see someone about that temper though.